Surveillance by the State – Data Collection and Human Rights?

The recent uprising and overtaking of the Afghanistan government by the Taliban has caused human right concerns to be pushed to the forefront of the world’s eyes and mind.. Data collection and storage may have devastating consequences for the citizens of Afghanistan.

Following Donald Trump’s deal with Taliban officials, Joe Biden still plans to withdraw all American Troops by 31 August with the UK aiming to remove troops but with no fixed date to help prevent a “humanitarian crisis”.[1] The Taliban has suggested the data will be held for the aim of reducing voter and welfare fraud with new surveillance measures due to be implemented, including, digital identity cards for Afghan citizens and the use of biometric information – fingerprinting, iris scans and facial recognition; these potentially supporting Edward Snowden’s 2013 suggestion that surveillance is a mere “keystroke away from totalitarianism”.[2]

Protecting Afghan Citizens:

Human Rights First – a human rights charity – has released a guide of how to avoid the misuse of biometric data and erasing your digital footprint for Afghan citizens;[3] this could be critical for survival, with some individuals now being persecuted for posting anti-Taliban content.[4]

The Human Rights Argument:

This, however is not an alien technology. Traditionally viewed ‘democratic’ societies like the US or UK use these forms of surveillance to protect their own citizens, but to what extent should this power be allowed to exist?

Subject to Article 8 of the European Convention on Human Rights, as  expressed in the Human Rights Act 1998,[5] is that

“Everyone has the right to respect for his private and family life, his home or his correspondence.”

This right is not to be interfered with by the state, however, there are the lawful excuses of necessity for reasons of “national security” and “public safety” amongst others. But how can a matter of public safety be accurately defined? In a democratic society the technologies may be used to prevent extremism or potential terror threats. In Afghanistan the same measures are being used to hunt-down citizens who do not promote the same values as the Taliban –which leads to the question could the same argument be used? Taliban officials may view Western ideals of democracy as a threat national security, therefore their actions would be justified as they were acting “for the prevention of disorder and crime”.

Solutions:

In the paperless age, we all should become more concerned with how governments are handling our data. Gone are the days of in-person destruction of files, with more advanced systems required to ensure data is adequately protected. Remote data destruction is a necessity so that devices are no longer accessible to those who would misuse private information. As the coalition forces withdraw from Afghanistan, these protections should have been enforced to prevent the theft of data leading to potential loss of life.


[1] Faulker, ‘Afghanistan: PM to press Biden to delay Kabul withdrawal’ https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-58301269 [Accessed: 23 August 2021]

[2] Naughton, “Beware state surveillance of your lives – governments can change for the worse” Beware state surveillance of your lives – governments can change for the worse | John Naughton | The Guardian [Accessed: 23 August 2021].

[3] Human Rights First, https://www.evacuateourallies.org/resources [Accessed: 23 August 2021].

[4] Lockhurst, “Taliban ‘carrying out door-to-door manhunt’” https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/live/world-asia-58219963 [Accessed: 23 August 2021].

[5] Human Rights Act 1998, Schedule 1: The Articles.

Warren v DSG: the end of data breach litigation for claimant firms?

 

A recent decision made in the High Court may significantly limit data breach litigation by claimant firms.

 

When a business suffers a data breach involving the personal data of its customers, claimant firms seek to sign up affected customers, issuing multiple claims for damages. Such claims are often for breach of the UK GDPR, breach of confidence, misuse of private information and negligence backed by confidential fee arrangements and After the Event (“ATE) insurance. Due to the perceived complexity of data claims and cost exposure created by ATE premiums, claimant firms have opted to create their own business model fuelled by out-of-court settlements.

 

In the case of Warren v DSG,[1] the defendants – Currys PC World (“DSG”) – suffered an external attack which resulted in the compromise of c. 10 million customer records, and a £500,000 fine by the UK Information Commissioner’s Office for violating the seventh data protection principle under the Data Protection Act 1998 (“DPA”) by not implementing appropriate security measures.

 

The claimant is one of these customers, who sought £5,000 for breach of the DPA (now replaced by the UK GDPR), breach of confidence, misuse of private information and negligence. Following claims for breach of confidence, misuse of private information and negligence being dismissed, the claimants were left with only a UK GDPR claim.

 

Such claims were dismissed for the following reasons: (1) all of the causes of action required some positive wrongful action to be taken, and there was no positive wrongful action in such circumstances as DSG was the passive victim of an attack, thus had not intentionally facilitated the data breach; (2) such actions do not impose any form of duty on DSG; and (3) there was no clinically recognised psychiatric harm in order to find a claim in negligence.[2]

 

The decision in Warren v DSG will have now considerably simplify the defence of similar claims, as well as making it increasingly difficult for claimant firms to recover ATE premiums in such cases due to the lack of a privacy claim, undermining the business model of claimant firms.

 

The judgement can be read here: https://www.bailii.org/ew/cases/EWHC/QB/2021/2168.html

 

[1] Darren Lee Warren v DSG Retail Limited [2021] EWHC 2168 (QB)

[2] https://www.shoosmiths.co.uk/insights/articles/data-breach-litigation-tap-brakes-end-road-claimant-firms

High-rise Lease-holders Can Now Sue Developers to Recover Fire Safety Costs

Following the Grenfell Tower fire in 2017, the country was forced to overhaul its building safety regime, which was later found to be inadequate. Many lease-holders of high-rise buildings have faced large costs to fix defects within their fire safety systems. The government has, now, introduced a plan to help these lease-holders recover such costs,  in introducing a longer period in which to take legal action.

The government has now published its Building Safety Bill, which changes the way tall buildings are to be designed, constructed and managed. The Bill has introduced the ‘Building Safety Regulator’ to oversee the process, encourage improvement and implement regulations as well as rendering all dutyholders responsible and accountable for a building’s safety during their relevant stage in the building cycle, including the building owner.[1]

Controversy has arisen, however, surrounding the government’s approach to protecting all leaseholders from paying to fix flaws that were not of their making, accumulating criticism even from some of its own party’s MPs.[2] The draft version of the Bill had included a clause that allowed building owners to charge developers for historical building safety costs pre-dating the residents moving in, as confirmed by UK Housing Secretary, Robert Jenrick. Campaigners had labelled this a ‘lawyers’ get-rich-quick scheme’.[3] The Housing, Communities and Local Government Select Committee have recommended that the clause is amended, such that the Bill explicitly excludes such costs from the charge, which the Government has now accepted.

The legislation, introduced on 5 July, will now only allow building owners to use the building safety charge to cover any ongoing costs of the new regulatory regime. Moreover, the legislation places a duty on building owners to explore and exhaust alternative cost recovery routes, before passing costs to leaseholders.

In addition to such amendments, the period of time in which leaseholders can sue developers is more than doubled, taking the claim period from 6 to 15 years; thus allowing the lease-holder of a property built in 2006 to still sue this year. Furthermore, the Bill has been extended to cover refurbishment work rather than merely construction of a dwelling. With more than 2000 high-rise buildings requiring refurbishment to fix fire safety issues, this is a significant amendment.

This Bill has not yet received royal assent, but is expected to do so by 2022.

[1] https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/draft-building-safety-bill

[2] https://www.insidehousing.co.uk/insight/insight/what-impact-will-the-building-safety-bill-have-the-key-takeaways-71452

[3] https://www.theguardian.com/society/2021/jul/04/high-rise-leaseholders-criticise-plan-to-help-them-sue-over-fire-safety-costs?CMP=Share_iOSApp_Other

EA Confirmed as Victims of Cybertheft

 

Major game publisher Electronic Arts (EA) revealed this month that hackers have stolen valuable information from the company. The attackers downloaded the source code for a number of high-profile games, including FIFA 21, and it is said that around 780GB of data was stolen. It has also been found that the source code for EA’s Frostbite game engine, a proprietary tool used to create dozens of games, as well as various frameworks and SDKs have been appropriated.

Exploit on EA services first came to light upon the publication of Motherboard’s report, claiming that the hackers made multiple posts on several underground hacker’s forums, now putting the 780GB of stolen data up for sale on said forums.

Hackers are reported to have used stolen cookies and Slack to target EA. They first purchased stolen cookies on the Dark Web for just $10, then used such cookies to gain access to a Slack channel used internally by EA, tricking one of EA’s IT department employees into providing two multifactor authentication login tokens over Slack.[1] This worryingly simple social engineering strategy provided the hackers with full access to the company’s corporate network.

The company has reassured that no customer data was stolen, adding that they “have no reason to believe there is any risk to player privacy”. EA have since stated that they have already improved their security following the incident. Officials do not expect the hack to impact its games or its business, as it was not a ransomware attack, thus the company’s data was not scrambled with encryption.

Although such a hack could risk games being copied by other developers, it is unlikely that any mainstream competitor to EA would decide to use such data. EA is currently investigating the data breach, working with law enforcement agencies to determine the full extent of the hack.

[1] https://www.vice.com/en/article/7kvkqb/how-ea-games-was-hacked-slack

China’s Zhurong Rover’s Selfie Released in Celebration of the Mission’s Success

 

China’s Zhurong rover landed on Mars on May 15, after spending seven months travelling from Earth and three months orbiting Mars. The robot has since sent a batch of images back.

One photo is of itself on Mars – a “selfie”. A second includes the rocket-powered platform that brought the rover to a soft touchdown, from which the vehicle drove down a ramp to get on to the surface. Both machines are adorned with Chinese flags.

There was also a picture looking out over the horizon from the landing site, an ancient impact basin in Mars’ northern hemisphere known as ‘Utopia Planitia’. The plain is the largest impact basin in the solar system, with an estimated diameter of 2050 miles.

These images were taken by a wireless camera carried by a tall mast, which also acts as the rover’s ‘eye’ to detect obstacles. The pictures were released by the Chinese space agency in celebration of the successful mission and the rover’s first month on the Red Planet, and introduced by the mission’s chief designer, Zhang Rongqiao.

The rover has six wheels and weighs 240kg, leaving visible tracks in the dust as it manoeuvred. Scientists are hoping to get at least 90 Martian days out of the robot. American space agency, Nasa, had two very similar vehicles in the 2000’s, ‘Spirit’ and ‘Opportunity’. Zhurong has a laser tool to zap rocks and assess their chemistry, much like the current American rovers, ‘Curiosity’ and ‘Perseverance’. It also has the ability to look for sub-surface water-ice due to a radar similar to that of Perseverance. This is to investigate whether Mark ever sustained life.

“There are consequences for failing to deal with litigation reasonably” – Challenge the evidence or you could face a wasted costs order.

 

 

Mina Heung, barrister of Whitestone Chambers secures costs award against Bott & Co on grounds of acting unreasonably in bringing claims that were bound to fail.

In the cases of Ebdon, Duffy and Liddle v KLM Royal Dutch Airlines[1], District Judge Trigg made a wasted costs order against Bott & Co Solicitors, a Flight Delay Compensation company.    The judgement provides an object lesson on the dangers of pursuing a futile case and for failing to challenge your opponent’s evidence.

This article looks at the question of burden of proof in a flight delay compensation claim under the EU Regulation EC 261/2004 and how Bott & Co was met with defeat and ordered to pay for the Defendant’s wasted costs for failing to deal with litigation reasonably.

The Case

EC 261/2004 requires airlines to compensate passengers when flight delays or cancellations result in passengers reaching their final destination more than three hours later than originally scheduled, unless the airline can establish on the defence in Regulation 5(3) which states that: “An operating air carrier shall not be obliged to pay compensation in accordance with Article 7, if it can prove that the cancellation is caused by extraordinary circumstances which could not have been avoided even if all reasonable measures had been taken.”

The Claimants brought actions against KLM for a cancelled flight, proceedings were issued on 11 May 2018.  KLM’s defence argued that the flight in question was cancelled at the request of Air Traffic Authorities.  On 23 August 2018, the claims were stayed by Liverpool County Court pending the appeal of Blanche v EasyJet[2].  On 6 February 2019, the Court of Appeal handed down its decision and ruled that disruption(s) caused by an Air Traffic Management Decision is deemed to be an extraordinary circumstance and that the Courts are not required to look at the reason behind the decision, meaning all airlines have to prove is the decision was made by the Air Traffic Control.  This is of course not the end of the matter,  as in order to rely on air-traffic management decisions under Regulation 5(3), airlines would still have to show that all reasonable measures had been taken to avoid the delay caused by the impact of the decision.

Following the decision in Blanche, KLM submitted direct evidence from Amsterdam Air Traffic Control Authority detailing the reason for the flight cancellation.  KLM further provided evidence to show that after considering a number of solutions, the claimants were put on the first available flight to their final destination, thereby discharging their duty on the “reasonable measures” requirement under the Regulation.

Notwithstanding the outcome of Blanche , the Claimants & Bott & Co still decided to argue the unarguable and prosecute the claims to trial by ignoring KLM’s evidence and counsel’s skeleton argument served ahead of the trial.  Bott & Co then elected to be absent at the trial on 7 October 2020 and pursued a written argument that runs contrary to the Court of Appeal’s decision in Blanche and contrary to the evidence provided by KLM, which was somewhat surprising as Bott & Co was the firm that represented Mrs. Blanche in her appeal to the Court of Appeal and lost.

The claims were eventually dismissed on the grounds of Bott & Co’s “audacious” legal arguments and the fact that KLM’s evidence regarding reasonable measures was not challenged at all – the claimants’ written submissions simply said that “the defendant has failed to support its contentions that reasonable measures were taken”.

An application for a wasted costs order pursuant to CPR 46.8 and section 51(6) of the Senior Courts Act 1981 against Bott & Co was immediately made by counsel at the conclusion of the trial.  At the costs hearing, Bott & Co admitted they were negligent in submitting and applying the wrong law but maintained that they were not wrong in pushing the claims to trial because despite the extraordinary circumstance arguments, KLM would still have to demonstrate they had taken all reasonable measures to minimise the delays caused to the passengers.  Whilst KLM accepted that they had to satisfy the “2-limb test” in order to successfully establish a defence under the Regulation, in the absence of any rebuttal evidence from the claimants and the fact that Bott & Co chose not to instruct representatives to attend the hearings and challenge KLM’s written and live evidence, the conclusion was inevitable given that the Court would only have KLM’s unchallenged evidence to rely on when making a finding.

In awarding wasted costs to the defendant’s, District Judge Trigg stated:

“With regard to the wasted costs order being sought against the legal representative, I have to consider whether the legal representative acted improperly, unreasonably, or negligently.  I take the view that they have acted unreasonably.

The answer to the question, “Has the conduct caused a party to incur unnecessary costs?” is “yes” and it is the costs of the hearing.  In answer to the question, “Is it just to order the legal representative to pay?”, the answer is “yes” to that as well.  There are consequences for failing to deal with litigation reasonably. “

There are a number of important lessons here: (i) know the law (ii) if you put a party to strict proof, do not just leave it here, unchallenged evidence will be accepted by the court (iii) know when to stop!  Even though you do not bear the burden of proof, examine the evidence before deciding to go to trial to avoid pursuing a hopeless case and facing a costs order.

© Mina Heung

Whitestone Chambers

[1] In the County Court at Staines, 4th December 2020

[2] Daniel Blanche v EasyJet Airline Company Limited [2019] EWCA Civ 69

“There are consequences for failing to deal with litigation reasonably” – Challenge the evidence or you could face a wasted costs order.

Mina Heung, barrister of Whitestone Chambers secures costs award against Bott & Co on grounds of acting unreasonably in bringing claims that were bound to fail.

In the cases of Ebdon, Duffy and Liddle v KLM Royal Dutch Airlines[1], District Judge Trigg made a wasted costs order against Bott & Co Solicitors, a Flight Delay Compensation company.    The judgement provides an object lesson on the dangers of pursuing a futile case and for failing to challenge your opponent’s evidence.

This article looks at the question of burden of proof in a flight delay compensation claim under the EU Regulation EC 261/2004 and how Bott & Co was met with defeat and ordered to pay for the Defendant’s wasted costs for failing to deal with litigation reasonably.

The Case

EC 261/2004 requires airlines to compensate passengers when flight delays or cancellations result in passengers reaching their final destination more than three hours later than originally scheduled, unless the airline can establish on the defence in Regulation 5(3) which states that: “An operating air carrier shall not be obliged to pay compensation in accordance with Article 7, if it can prove that the cancellation is caused by extraordinary circumstances which could not have been avoided even if all reasonable measures had been taken.”

The Claimants brought actions against KLM for a cancelled flight, proceedings were issued on 11 May 2018.  KLM’s defence argued that the flight in question was cancelled at the request of Air Traffic Authorities.  On 23 August 2018, the claims were stayed by Liverpool County Court pending the appeal of Blanche v EasyJet[2].  On 6 February 2019, the Court of Appeal handed down its decision and ruled that disruption(s) caused by an Air Traffic Management Decision is deemed to be an extraordinary circumstance and that the Courts are not required to look at the reason behind the decision, meaning all airlines have to prove is the decision was made by the Air Traffic Control.  This is of course not the end of the matter,  as in order to rely on air-traffic management decisions under Regulation 5(3), airlines would still have to show that all reasonable measures had been taken to avoid the delay caused by the impact of the decision.

Following the decision in Blanche, KLM submitted direct evidence from Amsterdam Air Traffic Control Authority detailing the reason for the flight cancellation.  KLM further provided evidence to show that after considering a number of solutions, the claimants were put on the first available flight to their final destination, thereby discharging their duty on the “reasonable measures” requirement under the Regulation.

Notwithstanding the outcome of Blanche , the Claimants & Bott & Co still decided to argue the unarguable and prosecute the claims to trial by ignoring KLM’s evidence and counsel’s skeleton argument served ahead of the trial.  Bott & Co then elected to be absent at the trial on 7 October 2020 and pursued a written argument that runs contrary to the Court of Appeal’s decision in Blanche and contrary to the evidence provided by KLM, which was somewhat surprising as Bott & Co was the firm that represented Mrs. Blanche in her appeal to the Court of Appeal and lost.

The claims were eventually dismissed on the grounds of Bott & Co’s “audacious” legal arguments and the fact that KLM’s evidence regarding reasonable measures was not challenged at all – the claimants’ written submissions simply said that “the defendant has failed to support its contentions that reasonable measures were taken”.

An application for a wasted costs order pursuant to CPR 46.8 and section 51(6) of the Senior Courts Act 1981 against Bott & Co was immediately made by counsel at the conclusion of the trial.  At the costs hearing, Bott & Co admitted they were negligent in submitting and applying the wrong law but maintained that they were not wrong in pushing the claims to trial because despite the extraordinary circumstance arguments, KLM would still have to demonstrate they had taken all reasonable measures to minimise the delays caused to the passengers.  Whilst KLM accepted that they had to satisfy the “2-limb test” in order to successfully establish a defence under the Regulation, in the absence of any rebuttal evidence from the claimants and the fact that Bott & Co chose not to instruct representatives to attend the hearings and challenge KLM’s written and live evidence, the conclusion was inevitable given that the Court would only have KLM’s unchallenged evidence to rely on when making a finding.

In awarding wasted costs to the defendant’s, District Judge Trigg stated:

“With regard to the wasted costs order being sought against the legal representative, I have to consider whether the legal representative acted improperly, unreasonably, or negligently.  I take the view that they have acted unreasonably.

The answer to the question, “Has the conduct caused a party to incur unnecessary costs?” is “yes” and it is the costs of the hearing.  In answer to the question, “Is it just to order the legal representative to pay?”, the answer is “yes” to that as well.  There are consequences for failing to deal with litigation reasonably. “

There are a number of important lessons here: (i) know the law (ii) if you put a party to strict proof, do not just leave it here, unchallenged evidence will be accepted by the court (iii) know when to stop!  Even though you do not bear the burden of proof, examine the evidence before deciding to go to trial to avoid pursuing a hopeless case and facing a costs order.

© Mina Heung

Whitestone Chambers

[1] In the County Court at Staines, 4th December 2020

[2] Daniel Blanche v EasyJet Airline Company Limited [2019] EWCA Civ 69

30 years celebrated at London Stansted Airport

March 2021 marks the 30th year anniversary for Stansted Airport since it’s opening in 1991. It’s been a long time since the conception of the airport and the pandemic has made those days of carefree travel seem even more distant – but it is still a cause for celebration!

Boasting a rich history, Stansted Airport may have only opened in 1991 but it’s operations have been running for more than 81 years. The first terminal dates back to 1942 and was involved in the major D-day bombings, helping military air force lead more than 600 craft over the beaches of France. Fast forward 40 years and Stansted was just starting construction on it’s new airport in 1986 – at the time the government enquiry accepted the construction on the grounds of bringing in 15 million passengers yearly. That number has grown over the years since it’s conception, with more than 100 million passengers passing through its gates in 2018. While the airport is now home to a wide range of carriers and crafts, some of its very first flights consisted of domestic services running to Glasgow as well as some Air France flights across the border.  Though the airport is known for its passenger and commercial travel above all, it is worth remembering that they also hold special importance for their involvement with the Air Force One and security airspace divisions. Its runways have seen Boeing-747s carrying space shuttles to assist Air Force One while also serving as the designated point for terrorist-diversion related incidents in airspace.

While its reputation as a low-cost airport has made it popular among travellers, COVID and subsequent lockdowns have taken its toll. Passenger levels have dipped dramatically during the pandemic, sometimes even down to double digits. However, with a lockdown exit plan starting to take shape the airport is confident it will be able to get back to its post-COVID numbers – and predicts that there will an uptake in the number of travellers once overseas travel is given the greenlight. The 30th anniversary of Stansted then comes as a bittersweet celebration but the airport is hopeful that bigger and better is yet to come. They may not be able to celebrate properly this month or welcome passengers back immediately, but they are on a road to recovery. Steve Griffiths, Stansted’s managing director, cited this cause for hopeful celebration in his comment to the press:

“We can’t wait to welcome back our passengers to begin the next 30 years of Stansted’s story, and we are confident the airport has a very bright and successful future once people are able to start planning for their well-deserved getaways.”[1]

[1] https://www.airinternational.com/article/london-stansted-marks-30th-anniversary-official-opening

© Whitestone Chambers

The rise and fall of Football Index

The popular self-styled ‘stock market for football’, now in administration and subject of a suspension by the Gambling Commission, enraged thousands of participants by reducing the share price of players leading to mass panic, financial losses and accusations that the company is nothing more than a ‘Ponsi’ scheme.

Football index describes itself as ‘the place to buy and sell shares in footballers for real money’. In practice, the platform was an extension of fantasy football but with real cash investments and real cash returns. Participants would buy ‘shares’ in footballers which would fluctuate in value depending on the performances of the players in games and by the demands of the market. By way of an example, if a participant bought 100 shares in a player for £1 each and that player later went on to have a great run of form, their share price might increase to £5 a share and said participant could then sell his 100 shares for £500 making a tidy £400 profit. As well as share prices, another feature of football index was cash dividends, summarised by joey d’Urso in his piece for the Athletic[1] as

“rather like fantasy football points but with real cash; pennies and pounds in the bank for owning shares in players who score goals or rack up assists and clean sheets. Dividends are also paid out for a player’s “media buzz’, quantified by mentions in mainsteam press outlets’.

Over recent years the popularity of football index has increased to the point where football index was a highly credible organisation sponsoring two championships football teams and advertised and discussed on many credible sports news outlets.  This seemingly upward trajectory of Football Index all changed last week however. In a post on their website on 5 of March football index posted the following:[2]

“To date, our Traders have enjoyed some phenomenal dividend increases year-on-year which have brought some incredible payouts. Continuing this trend is only possible in a buoyant market and the reality is we do not have that at the moment. In consultation with our legal and financial advisors we have had to make the very difficult decision that in order to ensure the long-term sustainability of the platform we simply must reduce dividends. As such, in accordance with our terms, we are giving 30 days notice regarding this change.”

 As a result of the announcement, share prices plunged. As panic set in and some participants decided to cut their losses and sell up, the share prices dropped further. Whilst football index markets itself as the ‘football stock market’, it is regulated by the Gambling Commission. Therefore, the risks involved are the same as any other gambling endeavor. In this case however the key difference is that people have not lost money because of gambling choices they have made, eg buying shares in a player that didn’t perform, but rather by the actions of the company and the subsequent reaction of the platform users who, in many cases, rushed to sell their shares fearing that their value was going to fall even further.

What has further infuriated users is that Football Index allowed new shares to be released allegedly at the same time that the company knew they were experiencing financial hardship with 300,000 new shares issued across the exchange in February. The announcement that the “phenomenal dividends” were to be reduced and that “Continuing with this trend (of phenomenal dividends) is only possible in a buoyant market and the reality is we do not have that at the moment” was taken by some to imply that dividends were paid using money brought in by new users. This led to the comparisons with a Ponsi, or pyramid, scheme where a constant supply of new money is needed to pay people higher up the pyramid which has a devastating effect then the new money at the bottom stops coming in.

After a week of panic and frustration, Football Index announced yesterday that they would enter administration. In a Company announcement released late last night, the company stated:[3]

“After much difficult deliberation we must now issue the following update.

 The Board of BetIndex Limited has consulted with external legal and financial advisors, and the UK and Jersey Gambling Commissions. The decision has been made to suspend the platform.

 The dividend restructure announced on Friday was a necessary step in a business recovery plan to seek the long-term sustainability of the platform. However, it is clear that this has not been well received and we need to find a more agreeable way forward.

 We are pursuing a restructuring arrangement to be agreed with our stakeholders including, most importantly, our community.  We are preparing this through an administration with insolvency practitioners Begbies Traynor, to seek the best outcome for customers with the goal of continuing the platform in a restructured form.”

Throughout today further news has emerged regarding the fate of Football Index. Queens Park Rangers announced on their website that they will no longer have the name of Football Index on their shirts, effective immediately. CEO Less Hoos said “As a football Club we entered into a one year agreement with Football Index in good faith. In light of recent events, the front property of QPR’s home and away strips will no longer spirt the football index logo”.[4] Nottingham Forest are expected to follow suit but no announcement has been made at this stage.

Also today, the Gambling Commission announced that they had suspended Football Index’ operating licence. The Commissions stated:

“The Gambling Commission has decided to suspend the operating licence of BetIndex Limited (t/a Football Index) pursuant to section 118(2) of the Gambling Act 2005.

The suspension follows an ongoing section 116 review into the operator, as we had concerns activities may have been carried on in purported reliance on the licence, but not in accordance with a condition of the licence, and that Football Index may not be suitable to carry on with licensed activities.

We have made it clear to the operator that as the investigation progresses, we expect it to focus on treating consumers fairly and keeping them fully informed of any developments which impact them.”[5]

This news will come as a massive blow to users of the gambling platform with sales and purchases now suspended.  Whilst the company went on to say in their statement that the administration and suspension of the platform was an interim step” to ensure that everyone’s rights are preserved in relation to funds held by BetIndex Limited.”, users will worry that there is no way back, particularly in light of the Gambling Commission suspension, and that their funds, in many cases amounting to life changing sums or lifetime Savings, will now be permanently lost.

[1] https://theathletic.com/2437087/2021/03/10/the-football-index-crash-more-akin-to-a-ponzi-scheme-than-betting-platform/

[2] https://trade.footballindex.co.uk/marketupdate-050321/

[3] https://trade.footballindex.co.uk/company-announcement-110321/

[4] https://www.qpr.co.uk/news/club-news/club-statement-football-index-120321/

[5] https://beta.gamblingcommission.gov.uk/news/article/information-notice-suspension-of-licence-betindex-limited

© Whitestone Chambers

 

RIAT 2021 Cancellation – Another Victim of Covid-19

Born from a long tradition of seeing military aircraft at play, the Royal International Air Tattoo (RIAT) is an annual event treasured by many. With the first air-show dating back to 1971, the RIAT holds a rich history and continues to appeal to many from aircraft enthusiasts and pilots alike. Despite its rich success and far-reaching appeal, COVID seems to have brought the event to a halt; a blow to many in the aerospace industry.

It was announced yesterday that the 2021 RIAT was cancelled and would be rescheduled to 2022.

“It is with great regret that the Directors of RAF Charitable Trust Enterprises have taken the difficult decision to cancel this summer’s Royal International Air Tattoo, which was due to take place at RAF Fairford, in Gloucestershire on July 16-18.”

One of many of COVID’s victims, the RIAT had been looking forward to its original 2021 date after an arduous 2020 of on and off lockdowns. However, the respite for celebration turned out to be a little too hopeful as the announcement curbed the RIAT from taking place for another year. Originally inspired by two air-traffic controllers, Tim Prince and Paul Bowen, the RIAT holds a special place in many people’s hearts. Growing to an event with a 3,500-volunteer stronghold with the help of the RAF, the RIAT brings a military air experience to its fans unlike any other. The groundswell of support and admiration for the air-show spans a wide range of people from aerospace industry experts, pilots, air-show enthusiasts to members of the RAF. News of the cancellation, therefore, came as a blow as hundreds were left to face the bleak reality of lockdown. For years, the event has provided an outlet for communities to get together and understand the military aerospace industry and has inspired many to work towards a military or aerospace career. The absence of RIAT in 2021 not only blows away opportunities for networking and development, but it also impacts all the other sectors involved with the show.

Providing hundreds with on-site jobs in catering, hospitality and event management, the cancellation of RIAT puts many economic benefits on hold until 2022. While it comes as a significant blow to all those involved in the show and the fans, it is important not to forget how important the RIAT could have been to the economy and employment status of many. If the show had taken place it would mark RIAT’s 50th anniversary in the military aerospace industry; a feat that now has to celebrated virtually. Despite the RIAT’s efforts to create a COVID-secure show complete with social distancing and masks, the Board eventually concluded that it was still too high of a risk to continue on. The RIAT provided a statement to the press on the cancellation due to safety measures:

“Whilst we understand that this decision will be met with disappointment by our many supporters, we know they recognise the responsibility we have, to all our stakeholders, to stage a safe and successful event. We hope that taking the decision now will provide clarity to all those involved in the air-show including our incredible army of volunteers, our loyal ticketholders, our valued suppliers, corporate guests and sponsors as well as the many military air arms from around the world who were hoping to join us in July to celebrate our 50th anniversary. We look forward and are determined to provide opportunities for this important milestone in the Air Tattoo’s history to be celebrated in 2021 including building on the incredible success of last summer’s Virtual Air Tattoo, details of which to follow.”

While the RIAT’s cancellation comes as a disappointment to many, it is for the greater good of the health and safety of the community. Many are positive that 2022 will signal a return to a new normal, perhaps even a better normal, where communities will be able to meet up again and take part in events like the RIAT that showcase the military might of Britain and its rich history.

© Whitestone Chambers