TIME FOR PHASE TWO – The Renters’ Rights Act and Landlord-Tenant Disputes
(No AI Has Been Used)
The Renters’ Rights Act 2025 represents a shift in the regulation of the private rented sector in England. Implemented to address longstanding issues, the Act aims to provide greater protection for tenants. However, as with the many reforms that have come before, the legal landscape is in a period of adjusting. Practitioners are warning that the reforms could inadvertently spur an increase in landlord-tenant disputes, as litigation becomes Odyssean in nature: longer, more complex and ever contentious.
Why Was Reform Needed?
The necessity of the Act was evident. The private rented sector has long been criticised for limited security of tenure for tenants and a higher proportion of properties failing to meet housing standards. Furthermore, private landlords in England were not required to belong to a redress scheme, leaving tenants to negotiate with their landlords directly and often enforce their rights through the courts- a costly and timely process.
The other side of the coin revealed its own issues: landlords reported significant problems recovering properties when tenants behaved antisocially or failed to pay rent. The Renters’ Rights Act 2025- which received Royal Assent on 27 October 2025- sought to strike a new balance, implementing commitments to give greater rights and protections to people renting their homes.
Phases of Implementation
The government is implementing the Act in three distinct phases.
Phase 1
This began back on 27 December 2025, whereby local authorities gained new powers to investigate whether private landlords or letting agents have broken certain laws, including powers to inspect properties and demand documents. Crucially, this phase introduced the new tenancy regime, converting assured shorthold tenancy into assured periodic tenancies with no end date. This phase also abolished Section 21 ‘no-fault’ evictions and reformed the grounds for possession.
Phase 2
The launch of a new database for the private rented sector will be seen under this phase on 15 December 2026. Landlords will have three months to register their property, with all actively letting landlords in England required to be registered by 14 November 2027. A new ombudsman service, which all private landlords will be required to join to provide fair, impartial and binding resolutions for tenant complaints, will be implemented after the database.
Phase 3
There will be a particular focus on raising standards, including a review of the Housing Health and Safety Rating System to make it more efficient for experts and easier to understand for landlords and tenants. The Act also introduces a decent home standard for the private rented sector, with local authorities empowered to enforce it.
The Rise of Disputes
The most significant procedural change- the abolition of Section 21 evictions is expected to be a primary driver of disputes. Kevin Kennedy, a partner at Burges Salmon LLP, notes that reforms make disputes more likely because landlords who had previously had a relatively straightforward route to possession must now prove why they are entitled to it.
“Our expectation… is that it will take longer to get possession and it will be more challenging,” says Kennedy. “The moment you have to prove something, that always means there is a greater level of complexity because there needs to be some evidence.”
Landlords must now also demonstrate that they are taking back possession for a specific reason under Section 8 of the Housing Act 1988, such as plans to sell or move into a property, rent arrears or antisocial behaviour. Sabrine Furneaux-Gotch, a partner at Mishcon de Reya LLP, highlights that the abolition of Section 21 also removes the accelerated procedure that allowed some possession claims to be decided on the papers alone. Landlords will instead have to take their case to a hearing and put evidence before a judge. She noted that, “There will be more possession claims in the court system, and more scope for disputes.”
Likely battles under Section 8 include landlords’ claims that they need a property back because they intend to sell it or live there themselves. Rent arrears may also be disputed if tenants claim they withheld money due to problems with the property or assert the landlord agreed to reduce what was owed.
Rent and Rising Costs
The Act also gives tenants new powers to challenge rent increases. Landlords can raise rent only once every 12 months and must give tenants two months’ notice. Tenants who believe the proposed figure is above the market rate can challenge it to be heard in HM Revenue and Customs’ Valuation Office.
However, early data suggests this process is already under strain. Analysis by the London Renters Union (LRU) of data from May to October 2026 showed that 80% of tenants who went through the tribunal process saw their rent go up by an average of £1,200 a year, although in most cases it was less than the landlord’s proposed increase. Tenants and landlords have reported increasingly long delays for hearings and a lack of consistency in how ‘fair market rent’ is being decided.
As the final phases of the Renters’ Rights Act roll out, the sector must brace for a more litigious landscape, where the pursuit of fairness for tenants may come at the cost of longer, more complex disputes for landlords and practitioners alike.
© Whitestone Chambers 2026
References:
Cromartry, H. (2026, October 9). Renter’s reform in England: What’s happening and when? UK Parliament House of Commons Library. Accessible at:
https://commonslibrary.parliament.uk/research-briefings/cbp-10669
Jones, W. (2026, October 19). Renters’ Rights Act Could Spur Landlord-Tenant Disputes. Law360. Accessible at:
https://www.law360.com/articles/2527709/renters-rights-act-could-spur-landlord-tenant-disputes
Murray, J. (2026, November 3). Rent rises of up to 88% still passing in England despite Renters’ Rights Act. The Guardian. Accessible at: